I’d like to thank Penelope and their PR partners for providing these samples with no strings attached.
Ever forget about an entire bottle of bourbon? I don’t mean that you had it the night before and it’s now empty and you don’t quite remember it being emptied. I mean that you set it with a bunch of other bottles and just sort of forgot it was back there? I admit that I might be in a fairly unique position to allow that to happen. But I’ve been sitting on these samples since at least the end of September, if not longer. They got stuck behind other samples and just got missed for a month or so.
Which is too bad, because I really like doing tastings of products from Penelope. Every single time we get one, it is either interesting, delicious, or both. This brand was built on a backbone of interesting blending, and I can’t remember a time when I thought they did a poor job at it. So yeah, I feel a little bad that this wasn’t timelier, as that initial email arrived on September 2nd.
Anyway, let’s get down to it. Tonight’s whiskeys are part of the 2026 Penelope Estate Collection, an annual series that shows off the brand's oldest and, quoting the email here, “most exceptional aged whiskey.” There are five bottles in this year’s lineup, and I’ll just quote the email again to save myself some typing:
Penelope Conundrum 12 Year Straight Rye Whiskey (NEW) - 12-Year Straight Rye, 101.5 proof, and the oldest straight rye whiskey release in Penelope’s history.
Penelope Founders Reserve 13 Year Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey - 13-Year Straight Bourbon, 101.4 proof, blended from the Master Blender’s favorite mash bill.
Penelope Private Select 10 Year Bourbon - Hand-selected 10-Year Straight Bourbon, 102.2 proof.
Single Barrel 10 Year Bourbon - The 2026 Single Barrel offerings feature two different mash bills and proof points:
Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 101 proof - Hand-selected 10-Year Straight Bourbon.
Single Barrel Straight Bourbon Whiskey, 107 Proof - Hand-selected 10-Year Straight Bourbon made with a higher-rye mash bill.
We ended up getting bottles of the Conundrum 12 Year Rye and the Private Select 10 Year Bourbon. Shall we dig in and see how they taste? Yeah, I thought so.
Penelope Private Select 10 Year Bourbon
Purchase Info: This bottle was sent to me at no charge for review purposes. They haven’t provided a suggested retail price yet, but I see that Total Wine lists it at $85.99 for a 750 mL bottle.
Price per Drink (50 mL): $5.73
Details: 51.1% ABV. 10 years old.
Nose: Stereotypical bourbon notes of vanilla, caramel, and oak, along with sweet cherry and chocolate.
Mouth: Sweet, with notes of caramel, chocolate, cherry, baking spice, and oak.
Finish: Warm and medium to long in length. Notes of baking spice, cherry, citrus zest, and oak.
Thoughts: First words out of my wife's mouth? “Oh, that's yummy.” Have to agree. Quite tasty. There is nice spice throughout. Fruit notes support the more stereotypical bourbon notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak. Just a lovely bourbon all around. I really like this.
Penelope Conundrum 12 Year Straight Rye Whiskey
Purchase Info: This bottle was sent to me at no charge for review purposes. They haven’t provided a suggested retail price yet, but I see that Total Wine lists it at $104.99 for a 750 mL bottle.
Price per Drink (50 mL): $7.00
Details: 12 years old. 50.75% ABV.
Nose: Strong caramel and chocolate, cedar, and cherry.
Mouth: Caramel, cedar, cinnamon, clove, cherry, honey, and oak.
Finish: Warm and long with notes of cinnamon, clove, cherry, honey, and oak.
Thoughts: Very rich and full in the mouth. Thick caramel and sweet honey are accentuated by cherry and baking spice notes of cinnamon and clove. This is absolutely delicious. I love this!
If you want to support our work at BourbonGuy.com, please consider a one-time donation at ko-fi.com/bourbonguy or paypal.me/BourbonGuy. Or you could buy some merch that I’ve designed and/or built (tasting journals, t-shirts, stickers, pins, signs, posters, and more) at BourbonGuyGifts.com. Use code BOURBONGUYREADER at checkout for 5% off any order of $50 or more.
