It has been three thousand, three hundred, and forty-five days since I last covered Old Bardstown Bottled in Bond by Willett Distilling. That’s just over nine years. I originally covered it back in 2016—I had gotten a tip that they would be releasing it at the distillery gift shop the next morning, and I grabbed two when I stopped in. The first bottle is what I reviewed originally, and the second got shoved into the back of the closet so that if I ever revisited it, I’d have something to compare the new one to.
That bottle sat in my office closet for almost nine years before I got on a step stool and realized it was still back there. Luckily for me, I had a trip through Kentucky coming up, and I decided to look and see if I could find a current release to compare to it. I did, and so here we are—taking a look at a 2025 version of Old Bardstown Bottled in Bond with a 2016 chaser. So what did I say about it oh so many years ago? Well, first and foremost, I said I liked it. Here’s the quote:
Twenty. Two. Dollars. For. A. Craft. Distilled. Bourbon! And it’s good! OK, to be fair, this is no world beater, but at $22, it doesn’t have to be. What it needs to be is solid, tasty, and work well either neat or in a cocktail. This does that. It’s a nice addition to the ranks of tasty, inexpensive bottled-in-bond bourbons. If you visit Kentucky, make sure this is in your bag when you leave.
So let’s see how 2025 stacks up.
Willett’s Old Bardstown Bottled in Bond
Purchase Info: $19.99 for a 750 mL bottle at The Party Source, Bellevue, KY
Price per Drink (50 mL): $1.33
Details: 50% ABV. Bottled in Bond (the product of one single distilling season).
Nose: Caramel, vanilla, cinnamon red hot candies, and almond.
Mouth: Follows the nose with notes of cinnamon red hots, vanilla, caramel, and oak.
Finish: Warm and on the longer side of medium. Lingering notes of cinnamon red hots and oak.
Thoughts: Quite tasty. This is a cinnamon bomb but also has a lot of classic bourbon notes. I'm digging this one. Very happy I decided to grab it back in May. I like it a lot. Now let's see how it has changed since the day-one release I've had stashed in my closet since the day of its initial release.
Comparison to 2016: Before I even purchased the bottle, I noticed that the price has remained amazingly steady over the last nine years—$20 in a large store now and $22 at the distillery gift shop then. Love that. Once I got the new one home, I also noticed that the new version has a shorter bottle and a different color closure. Then, when I got them into a glass, I couldn't help but notice the difference in color between 2016 and 2025. 2016 is much darker in the glass. On the nose, the 2025 is much sweeter. The perfect description of 2016 is spiced gum drops. By comparison, 2025 is super caramel/toffee forward. In the mouth, these are nothing alike—2016 seems more like it was trying to be interesting rather than good. Not that 2016 isn't good, but it has an unusual set of baking spice notes. Lots of clove and allspice, while 2025 is more of a classic vanilla/caramel bourbon flavor profile with a ton of cinnamon. At the end of the day, I appreciate the 2016 version, but I like the 2025 version. And weirdly, if you mix them equally, it turns into a “third” unrelated whiskey that is quite oak-forward. Fun experiment.
All in all, this stays a “like” rating.
